When owners try to purchase a collar for their dog’s exercise, they are often confused by the different terminology offered. In particular, owners may be confused about the differences between bark collars and training collars. Each of the tools mentioned has a specific target audience and purpose, and it is crucial to understand the differences between them before deciding which type to use. Today, we will outline the expectations of bark collars and how they differ from dog training collars. Then, you can easily determine which form of correction will best address your barking dog’s problem.
Bark collars work automatically with bark sensors.
A bark collar is essentially a device specifically designed to distract a puppy from barking. It is designed to negatively reinforce barking behavior and, over time, cause the dog to avoid the behavior. When your dog barks, the electronic bark collar detects vibrations in the vocal cords. When it detects these vibrations, a low-level shock is delivered to the dog’s neck. Specifically, it works in three ways: emitting a static stimulus; spraying a citronella solution; and emitting vibration.
In most cases, the bark is detected before any of the above stimuli are executed.
Bark collars are only used to correct dog behavior, including unprovoked barking. However, there has been a mixed response to the effectiveness of this tool. Also note that you do not have any remote control for the intensity level, you only can change it on the collar itself; therefore you have no remote to control over this.
With bark collars, these are always on. Please note, that you should not leave these collars on your dog permanently. By always on, we mean that you leave the collar in place and automatically provide corrections
For this reason, bark collars are ideal if you are away from home for a long time and you realize that your dog is barking too much and disturbing the neighbors. They can also be an effective overnight device if your dog tends to bark excessively when you try to sleep.
Remote training collars work manually with the handheld device you control.
They are also known as e collars, shock collars, or remote collars. The difference with bark collars is that you can trigger stimuli from a distance with remote control and choose stimuli such as shock, vibration, or sound. This method allows the dog to be more flexible in their exercises and can perform the various commands you teach them.
Most owners prefer remote training collars because there is more control over the process. The owner or trainer can control the dog from a distance, and the remote control has different buttons for a variety of training commands! It can be used to correct all types of bad behavior.
From controlling the intensity of the stimulus to the type of stimulus, it is fully equipped to train dogs of all temperaments.
Recommend Post:
The term shock collar technically refers to the same thing, but is usually used in a derogatory manner. Some balanced dog trainers have tried to reclaim the term “shock collar”, but “e-collar” is still the most commonly used term.
In terms of meaning, ‘shock collar’ is more of a collar with a shock feature, while ‘e collar’ perhaps includes both a shock and a no shock.
| Bark Collar | Remote Training Collar (e collar/shock collar) |
|---|---|
| Designed just for bark control | Designed for all types of both basic and advanced dog training |
| A single collar you place around your dog’s neck | A collar and handheld device you use to control the function of the collar |
| Only have one and sometimes two correction training Options | You can get remote training collar with all 3 of shock, vibration, and tone training options |
| Automatic bark sensing technology | Rely on you to deliver correction manually |
As you can see, both types of devices mentioned above do serve the same purpose: to train or correct bad behavioral traits in dogs. The main difference is that the remote training collar allows you to teach your dog from a distance and correct all types of behaviors. Therefore, it improves flexibility, while the use of a bark collar is qualitative in its operation and it only reduces excessive barking.
Need an expert? Our team helps you optimize your retail business and maximize your profits.
Just write down your name and email will get LATEST E-Catalog & Price List within 8 hours!
